Bobby Fish

Has there ever been a debut run as weak as Bobby Fish?

If wins matter in AEW, how is he JTTS material from day one?

Where does Fish go from here? Even a JTTS needs wins over lesser baby faces to build their name, or are they just run him based on UE rep?

They literally had him beat Lee Moriarty the night before he lost to Bryan Danielson in order to build him up exactly like you're saying here.  I don't even know what your complaint is, exactly.