Vicious Cycle

And no it's not a Sid Vicious question.
With Slammiversary being a great show, Impact seems to be continuing its trend of flipping between great and terrible every few months. This has been happening consistently over the past 3 or 4 years.

Is it safe to say that they have the best eye for talent since ECW, with the way they keep picking up acts after getting raided, getting those acts over, then getting those acts stolen by more reputable companies?

I literally haven't watched Impact since 2012 so you are asking the wrong audience.